Skip to content
Theatre Project Website Audit
Date: 11/28/25 Prepared by: Jeremy Dill

The current Theatre Project website is significantly outdated in design, performance, and safety. It no longer reflects the caliber of your mission, risks donor and grant trust, and creates barriers to engagement. A modern rebuild will not only solve urgent issues, it will position Theatre Project as a leader in the field and unlock more grants, donations, and community support.

Security First
Grant Ready
Mobile Optimized
Mission Driven UX
Concept hero for the new Theatre Project website
01

Security and Safety

Critical Issues
  • Outdated platform or plugins introduce security vulnerabilities.
  • Potential data exposure risk on donor and ticket forms.
  • No SSL or weak SSL implementation can trigger browser warnings.
  • Error messages such as “403 Forbidden” signal permission and configuration issues that undermine trust.
Recommendation

Immediate platform, plugin, and SSL audit with updates and monitoring. All donor and ticket workflows should be secured, hardened, and fully tested.

02

Mobile and Performance

Findings
  • Site is not fully responsive. Layouts break or look cramped on mobile and tablet.
  • Load times are slow due to unoptimized images, legacy code, and outdated plugins.
  • Mobile users, now the majority of web traffic, experience poor usability and drop off quickly.
Recommendation

Mobile first rebuild with modern frameworks. All images, scripts, and styles optimized for speed. Minimum target: core content loads in under 2 seconds on a typical 4G connection.

03

Design and Branding

Findings
  • Visual design is dated. Fonts, color palette, and UI elements do not match your mission’s vitality.
  • Brand voice is inconsistent and lacks emotional resonance.
  • Site lacks visual proof of community, impact, and the energy of your work.
Recommendation

Complete redesign with contemporary typography, color system, imagery, and custom graphics. Introduce storytelling modules that showcase impact, shows, behind the scenes content, and testimonials.

04

Navigation and User Flow

Findings
  • Navigation is cluttered or confusing.
  • Key actions such as donate, buy tickets, contact, and learn about the mission are hard to find or buried in menus.
  • Grant reviewers and first time visitors cannot easily answer: Who are you, what do you do, and how do I help.
Recommendation

Restructure menus with a clear, minimal hierarchy. Keep primary calls to action visible on every page. Map audience specific journeys for patrons, donors, press, and reviewers.

05

Accessibility and Inclusion

Findings
  • Low color contrast, missing alt text, and untagged images exclude visitors with disabilities.
  • Forms may not be fully keyboard accessible.
  • Lack of ARIA attributes and semantic markup reduces screen reader support.
Recommendation

Rebuild to meet or exceed WCAG 2.1 AA guidelines. Test all content with screen readers, keyboard navigation, and color contrast tools to ensure inclusive access.

06

Content and Storytelling

Findings
  • Outdated news, events, and donor lists reduce credibility.
  • Lack of recent photos, testimonials, or impact stories.
  • Static, text heavy pages discourage exploration and repeat visits.
Recommendation

Perform a content audit with mission first messaging. Install a CMS that allows rapid updates for shows, donors, press, and community features. Add visual storytelling, impact statistics, and real voices.

07

Donations and Conversions

Findings
  • Donation flow is unclear, multi step, or lacks trust signals.
  • No embedded, mobile friendly donation or ticket system.
  • No simple path for new donors, recurring gifts, or ticket buyers.
Recommendation

Streamline and secure the donation and ticketing flow. Integrate mobile ready payment solutions such as Stripe or GiveWP. Add donor recognition, recurring options, and clear proof of impact at key moments in the journey.

08

SEO and Discoverability

Findings
  • Metadata, headings, and schema are missing or misconfigured.
  • Internal linking structure is weak.
  • Events and press coverage are not optimized for search.
Recommendation

Full SEO overhaul including metadata, semantic structure, structured data for events and news, and improved internal linking. Build targeted landing pages for mission, programs, and signature shows.

09

Maintenance and Content Management

Findings
  • Site is difficult for staff to update, leading to stale content.
  • No clear backend process for events, donors, or news.
  • High dependency on a developer for basic changes.
Recommendation

Install a user friendly CMS such as WordPress or Webflow with custom dashboards for Theatre Project workflows. Train staff to update news, shows, donors, and images independently in a safe way.

10

Analytics and Reporting

Findings
  • No central dashboard for site visits, conversions, or donor activity.
  • Cannot demonstrate web impact for grants, reports, or the board.
Recommendation

Install analytics such as GA4 or Plausible with custom dashboards. Set up conversion tracking for donations, ticket sales, volunteer signups, and newsletter joins.

Summary

Status Overview

Area Status Key Issues Priority
Security Critical Outdated, possibly vulnerable, no SSL or visible errors. High
Mobile and Performance Poor Not responsive, slow load times, mobile drop off. High
Design and Branding Outdated Dated look and weak mission signal. High
Navigation and UX Friction Confusing navigation and hard to find key actions. High
Accessibility Lacking Not inclusive and fails basic standards. High
Content and Story Stale Old news and events with low engagement. Med High
Donations and Conversion Weak Unclear flows, trust issues, and missed gifts. High
SEO and Discovery Poor Missing metadata and limited optimization. Med
Maintenance and CMS Broken Hard to update; dependence on a developer. High
Analytics and Reporting Missing No tracking and cannot prove value. Med
This table gives your board and grant reviewers a clear, at a glance view of risk and opportunity. It also frames the rebuild as an investment in security, access, and growth.
Concept hero for the new Theatre Project website
Path

Upgrade Path / Next Level

Phase One

Secure foundation.

Fix hosting, SSL, and platform issues first so all other improvements sit on stable ground.

Phase Two

Mobile first redesign.

Deliver a modern, accessible, fast site that shines on every device and meets current expectations.

Phase Three

Mission driven content.

Roll out fresh, vivid, story led updates that invite donations, attendance, and sharing.

Phase Four

Conversion optimization.

Streamline donations, ticket sales, and volunteer flows to remove friction and increase revenue.

Phase Five

Empower staff.

Equip your team with a CMS and training so they can keep the story alive without high overhead.

Phase Six

Prove your value.

Use analytics and dashboards to show growth, engagement, and impact to your board and funders.

Why Now

Why Action Cannot Wait

  • Security risk. Every week with the current site risks data, trust, and brand reputation.
  • Grant success. Modern funders expect a site that signals credibility, innovation, and inclusion.
  • Audience growth. Mobile users and younger donors expect a fast, engaging, and accessible experience.
  • Internal efficiency. Staff need tools to maintain content without extra cost, delay, or risk.
Investment

Project Options For Theatre Project

Shared Baseline

Every option includes a full site relaunch. That means the complete Theatre Project map is brought up to current standards: homepage, productions, calendar, about, staff, education, support, donor information, contact, and existing static pages. Security, performance, accessibility, navigation, SEO, CMS, and analytics from this audit are addressed in each path.

Option 1 - Foundation Relaunch (approximately $1,500 to $1,750)
Secure, modern, reliable presence
  • Full redesign of all current pages with a calm, modern visual system that feels aligned with your mission.
  • Security, SSL, platform updates, and hardening so the site is safe for donors, partners, and staff.
  • Mobile first layouts and performance work so core pages load quickly on typical phone connections.
  • Clear navigation that answers three questions within seconds: who you are, what you do, how to get involved.
  • Accessibility upgrades so more of your community can participate without barriers.
  • Simple CMS structure so staff can keep pages current without technical help.

This option treats the website as a clean, reliable instrument. It removes friction, restores trust, and makes Theatre Project look as serious and thoughtful as the work on your stage.

Option 2 - Story And Supporter Engine (approximately $2,200 to $2,500)
Make the mission unforgettable
  • Everything from the Foundation Relaunch across all pages.
  • Mission forward storytelling blocks that show real people, real impact, and the history of the work.
  • Event and news sections that stay fresh with light automation so nothing feels stale to a funder or donor.
  • Impact panels that make outcomes visible for board members, grant reviewers, and major donors at a glance.
  • Guided paths for donors, partners, and artists so each group knows exactly what to do next.
  • Social proof patterns that show who has trusted you, which signals safety and momentum to new supporters.

This option treats the website as your public narrative. It shapes how people feel about Theatre Project before they meet you in person and uses that perception to support grants, partnerships, and giving.

Option 3 - Ticket And Mission Engine (approximately $3,000)
Turn visits into full houses
  • Everything from the Story And Supporter Engine across all pages.
  • A focused ticket journey that removes every extra step that does not serve one goal: buy a ticket in under a minute on any device.
  • Show and season pages designed like simple funnels: clear hook, emotional story, proof, then a single obvious action.
  • Placement of urgency and scarcity where it helps, such as limited runs, closing dates, and final performances.
  • Micro copy and layout that answer unspoken questions: where is this, who is this for, will I enjoy it, is it safe to pay here.
  • Email and interest capture points around shows and programs so casual visitors can become future ticket buyers and supporters.
  • Lightweight analytics and conversion tracking on ticket interactions and key calls to action so you can see what is working and adjust.

This option treats the website as a working front of house. It aligns design, language, and structure so the natural outcome of a visit is a ticket purchase or a meaningful act of support, while still honoring the depth of the mission.

All options begin with a project deposit to lock scheduling and kickoff. The remaining balance is due on launch. The difference between options is not whether the site is fixed, it is how far we lean into storytelling and revenue so the site becomes a true engine for Theatre Project.
Next

Next Steps

  1. Review and approve this audit with your board and key stakeholders.
  2. Select the project option that best matches your goals and place the deposit to lock strategy and kickoff.
  3. Begin the upgrade journey: discovery, preview, launch, and post launch tuning.
Visuals

Concept Visuals For The Relaunch

Concept hero for the new Theatre Project website
Mission First Homepage

A clean, mobile ready hero that states who you are, what you do, and how to get involved, in seconds.

Concept hero for the new Theatre Project website
Frictionless Ticket Journey

A simple path from show discovery to confirmed ticket that works smoothly on any device.

Concept hero for the new Theatre Project website
Donor And Impact View

Clear panels showing impact, partners, and outcomes that help grants, donors, and board see the value.

Prepared by: Jeremy Dill

Date: 11/28/25

Studio: Synsian.Com - Aiuci.com